|
City
of Saskatoon helps local cycling businesses
protest proposed 30% surtax
on imported bicycles
Background:
On September
1, 2005, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal (CITT) recommended
that the Government of Canada impose a 30% surtax on certain bicycles
primarily imported from developing countries. The CITT issued its recommendation
in response to a complaint filed by two companies, Raleigh and Procycle,
that already are protected by two layers of Canadian border protection
an unusually high 13% customs tariff that is applied to every bicycle
imported into Canada and antidumping duties that have been imposed on
bicycles from Taiwan and China for more than a decade.
The new
surtax will hurt our locally owned, independent bicycle dealers. These
are the businesses that sell the bicycles affected by this tax. These
are the shops that sell the bikes that we ride.
In response
to this threat to independent bicycle dealers and the tens of thousands
of cyclists they serve, Saskatoon's bicycling industry asked for Saskatoon
city council's help in opposing this unfair tax. Here is the correspondence
that transpired on this issue, followed by links to sites with more infomation.
Letter
to Saskatoon City Council:
November
14, 2005
His Worship
the Mayor and Members of City Council:
RE: Surtax
on Imported Bicycles
On September
1, 2005, the Canadian International Trade Tribunal (CITT) recommended
that the Government of Canada impose a 30 percent surtax on certain bicycles
imported primarily from developing countries.
Saskatoon's
independent bicycling businesses and their more than 120 employees request
the support of Saskatoon City Council in urging the federal government
not to impose this tax because it is not in the public interest.
The CITT
issued its recommendation in response to a complaint filed by two companies,
Raleigh and Procycle. These companies are already protected by two layers
of Canadian border protection an unusually high 13 percent customs
tariff that is applied to every bicycle imported into Canada and antidumping
duties that have been imposed on bicycles from Taiwan and China for more
than a decade.
The independent
bicycle dealer is crucially important to the future of the Canadian bicycling
industry. It would not be in the public interest to add a third layer
of protection for the following reasons:
- Higher
bicycle prices will discourage healthy family recreational activity
at a time of rising concern over the physical fitness of Canadian adults
and children.
- Given
Canada's Koyoto commitments regarding greenhouse gas emissions, environmentally
friendly means of transportation should be encouraged, not discouraged.
- It does
not make sense to impose additional taxes on cycling when rising gasoline
prices are making driving unaffordable to many Canadians.
- It is
unfair to hurt hundreds of independent bicycle dealers locally
owned and operated businesses to protect a relatively small number
of jobs in a couple of towns.
- Imposing
protectionist barriers on imports from developing countries will not
help Canada to diversify and grow its trade with these increasingly
important trading partners.
Saskatoon's
local bike shops are the cycling lifeblood of the community. The staff
and owners of these shops are dedicated to cycling for sport, recreation
and transportation. They volunteer their time to local clubs, they sponsor
or organize events and they support local charities. Anyone who relies
on their bicycle also depends on their independent bicycle dealer for
parts, service, advice and reliable bicycles.
The CITT
recommendation, while focussed on mass bikes, actually increases the cost
of all imported bikes (including children's bikes) priced below about
$650. This will cause sales to drop, and jobs and business to be lost.
The CITT
recommendation is opposed by other Canadian bicycle manufacturers, the
Bicycle Trade Association of Canada, Canadian municipalities, independent
business owners, and thousands of cyclists. In response to the legitimate
concerns of the industry and Canadian cyclists, the Canadian Bicycle Manufacturers'
Association (whose sole members are Procycle and Raleigh) has hired one
of the top lobbying firms in Canada, Earnscliffe Strategy Group. This
firm includes former Liberal cabinet ministers, the former Chairman of
the Liberal Party leadership campaign, and other former Liberal Party
insiders including senior advisors to the Hon. Prime Minister Paul Martin.
This city's
cycling businesses request that Saskatoon City Council write to the Federal
Ministers of Environment, Health, International Trade, Sport, Finance,
Transport, Infrastructure, Public Health and Families, and to the Members
of Parliament representing Blackstrap, Saskatoon-Humboldt, Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar
and Saskatoon-Wanuskewin constituencies, to express support for local
businesses and strongly urge the government not to impose this tax.
The bicycling
organizations and their employees represented by the signatures below
respectfully request Saskatoon City Council to pass the following resolution
at its next Council meeting:
THAT WHEREAS:
1. The Canadian International Trade Tribunal is recommending that the
Canadian government impose a 30% surtax on imported bicycles with a wheel
size of 15" or greater with a F.O.B. factory price of $225 or less,
to protect jobs for two bicycle assembly companies in Quebec;
2. And whereas this surtax is on top of existing tariffs of 8.513%
on all imported bicycles, as well as anti-dumping duties;
3. And whereas this surtax is strongly opposed by all but two Canadian
cycle manufacturers and by nearly 1,000 independent specialty retail bicycle
stores across Canada;
4. And whereas these dealers estimate that this tax would add an estimated
$50 to the price of the lowest-cost mass market bicycles, making a first
bicycle purchase prohibitively expensive for many children and families;
5. And whereas cycling is
a transportation priority for the City of Saskatoon,
a key factor in reducing youth and adult obesity,
essential for Saskatoon meeting environmental and conservation
goals and
a vital element of a healthy city;
THEREFORE
BE IT RESOLVED that Saskatoon City Council shall send a letter to the
Federal Ministers of Environment, Health, International Trade, Sport,
Finance, Transport, Infrastructure, Public Health and Families, and to
the Members of Parliament representing Blackstrap, Saskatoon-Humboldt,
Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar and Saskatoon-Wanuskewin constituencies, strongly
urging the government not to impose this tax.
We hope that
you will support the foregoing resolution and help Saskatoon's bicycling
businesses continue to serve the 160 competitive cyclists, 2700 cyclists
who cycle to work , and125,000 casual and recreational cyclists who make
up the 180,000 bicycle owners in Saskatoon. Additional background information
is appended to this letter.
Should you
wish to discuss any of the foregoing prior to the City Council meeting,
please do not hesitate to contact any of the organizations shown below.
Sincerely,
Saskatoons
Bicycling Industry:
- Borealis
Outdoor Adventure, 8B-305, 3110 8th St E, Saskatoon, SK S7H 0W2
(306) 343-6399
- Bike Universe,
730A Broadway Ave, Saskatoon, SK S7N1B4 (306) 244-0200
- Bike Doctor,
623 Main St, Saskatoon, SK S7H0J8 (306) 664-8555
- Broken
Spoke, 149 Jessop Ave, Saskatoon, SK S7N1Y3 (306) 242-5304
- Bruce's
Cycle Works, A-1104 Central Ave, Saskatoon, SK S7N2H1 (306) 934-2552
- City Park
Cycle, 614 Duchess St, Saskatoon, SK S7K0R1 (306) 384-2282
- Doug's
Spoke'n Sport Inc, 31A-2105 8th St E, Saskatoon, SK S7H0T8 (306) 373-4224
- Jad's
Cycle & Skate Repair, 434 20th St W, Saskatoon, SK S7M0X4 (306)
653-1803
- MWD Industries,
Cellular Telephone, Saskatoon, SK (306) 280-3990
- Outtabounds,
105 Ave B S, Saskatoon, SK S7M1M2 (306) 244-7813
Cover
Letter to Saskatoon City Council:
November
21, 2005
His Worship
the Mayor and Members of City Council:
RE: Surtax
on Imported Bicycles
I am writing
to express my support for Saskatoon's bicycling industry, whose 10 businesses
with more than 120 employees request City Council's help in opposing a
proposed 30 percent surtax on bicycles.
There are
365 club cyclists in Saskatoon, 2700 cyclists who cycle to work , and
125,000 casual and recreational cyclists who make up the 180,000 bicycle
owners in Saskatoon. All of these citizens will be harmed by this new
tax if it is implemented. For parents, this tax will result in a $45
$55 increase in the price of a typical children's bicycle for every
bicycle purchased in the family. For the average commuter bicycle, this
surtax will raise the price by about $150. This tax does not help the
bicycle dealer. It does not help our citizens. It simply makes bicycles
more expensive for the average person.
Thank you
for considering the request made by Saskatoon's bicycling industry.
Yours sincerely,
Darrell Noakes,
President
Correspondence
received from Saskatoon City Council:
From
the:
City of Saskatoon
Office of the City Clerk
222 - 3rd Avenue North
Saskatoon, SK S7K 0J5
December
5, 2005
Mr. Darrell
Noakes, President
Borealis Outdoor Adventure Inc.
8B-305, 3110 - 8th Street East
Saskatoon, SK S7H 0W2
Dear Mr.
Noakes:
Re: Proposed
Surtax on Imported Bicycles (File No. CK. 1915-1)
City Council,
at its meeting held on November 28, 2005, considered your letter dated
November 21, 2005, with respect to the above matter. Council passed the
following motion:
1) that
City Council send a letter to the Federal Government, urging the government
not to impose the proposed surtax; and
2) that
a copy of Council's letter be forwarded to the Saskatchewan Urban Municipalities
Association.
I have attached
a copy of the letter that has been forwarded to the Federal Government,
as well as the Saskatchewan Urban Municipalities Association.
Yours truly,
Janice
Mann, City Clerk
From
the:
City of Saskatoon
Office of the City Clerk
222 - 3rd Avenue North
Saskatoon, SK S7K 0J5
December
5, 2005
Honourable
Stéphane Dion
Minister of the Environment |
Honourable
Vjjal Dosanjh
Minister of Health |
Honourable
Scott Peterson
Minister of International Trade |
Honourable
Jean-C. Lapierre
Minister of Transport |
Honourable
Ralph Goodale
Minister of Health |
Honourable
John Ferguson
Minister of State
(Infrastructure and Communities) |
|
Honourable
Carolyn Bennett
Minister of State
(Public Health)
|
Honourable
Stephen Owen
Minister of State
(Sport) |
Lynne
Yelich, MP
Blackstrap |
Bradley
Trost, MP
Saskatoon-Humboldt |
Carol
Skelton, MP
Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar |
Maurice
Vellacott, MP
Saskatoon-Wanuskewin |
Dear Ministers
and MPs:
Re: Proposed
Surtax on Imported Bicycles (File No.CK. 1915-1)
The Council
of the City of Saskatoon, at its meeting held on November 28, 2005,
considered the attached letter dated November 14,
2005, from ten local businesses in the bicycling industry, asking for
Council's assistance in opposing the proposed 30% surtax on bicycles.
City Council
shares the concerns outlined in the letter, particularly with respect
to efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and to increase physical
fitness levels of Canadian Citizens. Council has instructed me to write
to the Federal Government, urging the government not to impose the proposed
surtax.
Yours
truly,
Janice
Mann, City Clerk
cc: Saskatchewan
Urban Municipalities Association
Links:
- Canadian
International Trade Tribunal recommendation
- Bike
Protectionism, by Pierre Lemieux
- Councillor
Peter Ladner to ask City Council to oppose national bicycle surtax,
by Peter Ladner
- CITT
Recommendations Released, Pedal Magazine
- OGC
Responds To CITT's Report On Imported Bikes, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
Tariff Ruling Update, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
On Line Petition and Protest Ride, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
Issue Heats Up, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
2005 Update - Procycle Responds, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
2005 - CASBI Update, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
2005 - IBRC Responds,
Pedal Magazine
- City
of Saskatoon Opposes Bicycle Surtax, Pedal Magazine
- CITT
2005 Bicycle Surtax is Election Issue, Pedal Magazine
- Cabinet
considers surtax on Chinese bicycles, by David Akin, CTV News
- Liberals
consider alternatives to bike surtax, CTV.ca News Staff
- Canadian
trade being hurt by Liberal inaction, by Ted Menzies, MP
- A
Bicycle Built For Two, by Paul Summerville, MP
- BTAC
Announces Oppositon to CITT Recommendations, Bicycle Trade Association
of Canada
- The
Proposed 30% Surtax on Bicycles is not in the public interest,
Canadian Association of Specialty Bike Importers
- Bicycle
Surtaxes approved by Canadian Panel: This could affect you,
by Cam McRae, NSMBe.magazine
- Canadian
IBDs say import surtax will kill them off, BikeBiz online
- Canadian
retailer fights bike import tax, BikeBiz online
- Canadian
IBDs and bike distributors unite against surtax, BikeBiz online
- City
council supports IBDs over Canadian bike surtax, BikeBiz online
Related
item
News index page
|